shutter & wash
← the archive
Winslow Homer, Boys in a Dory
Winslow Homer, Boys in a Dory. watercolor washes and gouache over graphite underdrawing. 1873. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Open Access. source record for Boys in a Dory ↗
Entry No. 03 ·Identity

What has stayed true in every version of me?

The boat is small against the open water.

A few boys share it, and that is the part I keep returning to: they are not alone.

We often talk about change as if we leave the old self behind, but some things do need to be released: old habits, old roles, old dreams made for weather that no longer exists. Still, one quiet thing often keeps moving with us. The boat changes. The water changes. We change. Something familiar still comes along.

The past is not a stranger. It is more like an earlier shoreline. You may not live there now, but you still know its shape.

What stays is not always a trait you can name quickly. Often it is a way of meeting the world, and for me it is noticing. I notice the pause before someone answers, the light on the kitchen floor, the way a person says, “I’m fine,” when the sentence has no weight behind it, and a friend sending a photograph with no explanation because they know I will understand why it matters.

That way of seeing changed as I changed. When I was younger, noticing felt close to worry, and I watched everything because I thought attention might prevent loss. Later, it became gratitude. The same quality can take a new shape over time: a child’s sensitivity can become an adult’s empathy, and a restless need to escape can become the courage to begin again. The raw material stays familiar, even when the form changes.

No one keeps an identity alone. We carry pieces of one another, and other people carry pieces of us. A friend may remember a version of you that you can no longer reach easily, and someone who loves you may hold a map of your life that includes roads you forgot. Identity is partly shared, not because other people get to define you, but because a life is made with others.

That is part of what I see in the boat. Balance is never only one person’s work: someone notices the clouds, someone steadies the side, someone keeps rowing. Continuity is not a straight line, and a life can look inconsistent from the outside and still be true.

Sometimes the most honest thing you can do is stop pretending the old direction still works. A boat headed toward the wrong shore is not being loyal by refusing to turn.

Hard weather clarifies things. It removes the decoration and shows what the boat is made of. In those seasons, what remains may be very small and very real: telling the truth to one person, asking for help, answering one message, washing a cup. The self that survives a storm is not always the self that planned for it.

I do not want to stay exactly the same. I want to keep the parts that make life feel connected. I hope I keep noticing beauty without needing to own it, stay interested in other people’s hidden weather, and keep making room in the boat while learning which parts are alive enough to carry forward.

Maybe that is what staying true means. Not preserving every piece, but keeping what is still living, still honest, still able to reach for others when the water changes.

What is one quality, relationship, or way of seeing that has stayed with you through every version of your life?